Are We Losing Our Literary Edge? A Book Enthusiast's Take on Modern Reading vs Classic Literature
- Kat Collins
- Aug 18
- 4 min read
Updated: Sep 3
In the fast-changing world of literature, a passionate discussion is taking place among book lovers: Are we losing our literary edge? As someone who loves reading, I often reflect on the differences between modern reads and classic literature. Are today's authors simplifying their work, or are they just catering to the shifting interests of their audience? Let's explore the nuances of this literary landscape and discover if, as readers, we are indeed losing our edge!
The Allure of Classic Literature

Classic literature possesses a timeless charm that continues to draw readers in. Works by authors like Jane Austen, Charles Dickens, and J.R.R. Tolkien offer deep insights into what it means to be human. These novels are rich, featuring complex characters and intricate plots that prompt thoughtful reflection. For instance, Pride and Prejudice challenges societal norms and personal biases, still relevant over 200 years later!
Reading a classic can transport us to different eras and cultures. Although the language may seem difficult, the themes of love, loss, and morality resonate today. A study found that reading classic literature can increase empathy, as it encourages readers to understand characters' emotions and experiences deeply. This kind of engagement offers a rewarding opportunity to connect with people from other times and backgrounds.
The Rise of Modern Literature

In contrast, modern literature mirrors our fast-paced, technology-driven lifestyle. Authors today experiment with various forms and styles, often prioritizing easy readability and relatability. This has led to the rise of genres like young adult fiction, dystopian narratives, and memoirs. For example, The Hunger Games series has sold over 26 million copies, demonstrating the demand for accessible storytelling!
Many believe modern authors are dumbing down their narratives, but I see it differently! They respond to contemporary readers’ needs, creating stories that are engaging and easy to digest while still holding deep meanings. This shift in focus does not diminish depth; it often presents complicated ideas in a format that resonates with today's audience.
Are Authors Underestimating Us?
A major point of contention in this discussion is whether authors perceive us as "dumb," which is something I've been seeing a lot lately on the divisive BookTok. The simplification of language and themes in modern literature might seem condescending. However, I argue that it is more about making literature accessible! Authors often aim for a wider audience, which requires them to craft relatable stories for a diverse readership.
The literary world is expansive, allowing space for both classic and contemporary works. Just because a book is easier to read does not mean it lacks merit. Many authors today tackle weighty topics like identity, mental health, and social justice. They often use straightforward language to spark meaningful discussions among readers. For example, Marcus Kliewer's hit, We Used To Live Here, was quite an easy read, but thought-provoking and unforgettable!
The Importance of Diverse Reading
As an avid reader, I strongly encourage having a diverse reading list that includes both classic and modern literature. Each has unique perspectives that can broaden our understanding of the world! By exploring a variety of literary works, we enrich our appreciation of storytelling and the myriad ways authors convey their messages.
Reading classics offers a foundation for grasping the themes and motifs prevalent in modern literature. Conversely, contemporary works can illuminate present-day societal issues and the human experience in our current context. By embracing both, we sharpen our minds and enhance our literary appreciation!
The Role of Technology in Reading

Technology has fundamentally changed how we interact with literature. E-books, audiobooks, and online platforms have made reading more accessible than ever! However, this shift raises questions about the depth of our reading experiences. Are we skimming through texts, or are we truly connecting with the content?
While some suggest that technology contributes to a decline in literary depth, I view it as a chance for growth! Digital platforms foster interactive storytelling and diverse formats, engaging readers in innovative ways. The challenge lies in striking a balance between convenience and depth, ensuring we continue to challenge ourselves with our reading choices.
While I love the feeling of a book in my hands, I personally read on a Kobo Clara Colour. I can link my library card to it and digitally check out books from my local library. This single feature has allowed me to read many books that I may never have explored, all while saving me time and money!
Embracing the Literary Journey
The debate between modern literature and classic works is not about determining which is superior. It is about recognizing the value in both forms and understanding how they reflect our world! As book lovers, we should celebrate the diversity of literature and actively seek works that challenge and inspire us.
Are we losing our literary edge? Perhaps, but it's not too late to reclaim it! By reading widely, exploring different genres, and appreciating storytelling's evolution, we can ensure that our passion for literature remains vibrant. So, let’s dive into that classic novel alongside the latest bestseller and continue our journey through the captivating world of books!
Conclusion
In summary, the landscape of literature is vast and diverse, catering to a wide array of tastes and preferences. Overall, while I can agree that some authors I have read of late have felt a bit... elementary, I can also agree that those authors are not writing for me. I recently read a book that was all over social media, being touted as a masterpiece of modern literature, and it was all I could do to finish it! It was honestly the worst thing I have ever read. However, the thousands of people that loved this book are who it was written for, and I can at least appreciate that much of it. This experience underscores the importance of recognizing that literature resonates differently with each reader.
While not every book will speak to us, the variety in writing styles and themes ensures that there is something for everyone! Embracing this diversity allows us to celebrate the unique ways in which stories can connect with different audiences, even if they do not connect with us personally.
What do you think? Sound off below!
If you would like to check out the Kobo Clara Colour for yourself, click here and see if it's a good fit for you! I also highly recommend getting the screen protector. It still has the paper matte finish, but it has saved my screen!






Comments